This review focuses on Dior's Crayon Eyeliner, Waterproof edition in Black. While marketed as a high-end, long-lasting product, my experience reveals a more nuanced reality. Let's delve into the specifics, comparing it to other Dior eyeliners and similar products on the market. My overall conclusion? It's decent, but not revolutionary, and its waterproof performance is surprisingly comparable to drugstore alternatives, leaving me slightly disappointed considering the price point.
First Impressions and Application:
The Dior Crayon Eyeliner arrives in a sleek, classic Dior black tube. The packaging feels luxurious, reflecting the brand's prestige. The eyeliner itself is a smooth, creamy texture that glides on easily. Initial application is a dream; the pigment is rich and intensely black, delivering a bold, opaque line with minimal effort. This is where the product shines. Building up the intensity is also straightforward, allowing for both subtle and dramatic looks. The slightly thicker tip allows for both precise lines and easy smudging for a softer, smoky effect immediately after application. This versatility is a definite plus.
Waterproof Performance: The Verdict
The "waterproof" claim is where the Dior Crayon Eyeliner falls short of expectations. While it does offer decent water resistance, its performance is not significantly superior to many drugstore waterproof eyeliners. I subjected it to a series of tests, including splashes of water, sweating during exercise, and even a deliberate attempt to smudge it with a wet cotton pad. While it didn't completely run, it did show some smudging, especially in areas prone to creasing, like the outer corners of the eyes. My experience puts its water resistance on par with a comparable, much more affordable eyeliner from a different brand – a disappointing revelation considering the price difference. This isn't a complete failure; it held up reasonably well, but it didn't meet the high expectations set by the "waterproof" label and the brand's reputation.
Comparison to Other Dior Eyeliners:
To provide a more comprehensive review, let's compare the Dior Crayon Eyeliner to other eyeliners within the Dior range:
* Dior Diorshow On Stage Liner Eyeliner: This liquid eyeliner is known for its intense pigmentation and precise application. It offers superior staying power and superior waterproof capabilities compared to the Crayon Eyeliner, although it requires a slightly steadier hand for application. The Diorshow On Stage Liner is a better choice for those seeking longer-lasting, smudge-proof wear.
* Diorshow On Stage Eyeliner (Pencil): While I haven't personally tested this specific pencil liner, online reviews suggest it offers a similar creamy texture to the Crayon Eyeliner, but possibly with slightly better staying power. This would warrant further investigation.
* Dior Stylo Waterproof Eyeliner: This is another contender from Dior's lineup. While I haven't personally used this product, based on online reviews, it seems to offer comparable waterproof performance to the Crayon Eyeliner. The key difference likely lies in the specific formula and application method.
* Diorshow Waterproof Eyeliner: This is a broad category encompassing various Dior eyeliners with waterproof properties. The Crayon Eyeliner falls under this umbrella, but its performance doesn't necessarily distinguish itself from other products within the same category.
current url：https://dqwajl.e171z.com/bag/dior-eyeliner-review-14556